“Where the Wild Things Are” follows the adventures of Max, a head-strong young boy who leaves home after having a fight with his mother — only to find himself in a mysterious forest bordering a vast sea. Misunderstood and rebellious, Max sets sail to the land of the Wild Things, where mischief reigns.
Swanner: Last night Brian and I saw Where the Wild Things Are which is an adaptation of Maurice Sendak’s classic children’s story, where Max, a disobedient little boy who after an altercation with his mother, creates his own world–a forest inhabited by ferocious wild creatures that crown Max as their ruler. They play they fight and he goes home…One hour and forty five minutes later I’m in my car wondering WTF I just watched.
Judd: The movie is based on a 120 word book that was revolutionary in 1963 in the way that it dealt with the emotions of a child such as anger and loneliness. Author Maurice Sendak teamed up with director Spike Jonez to put the book on film. I thought it worked. The meandering plot was filled in with beautiful imagery – just like the book. However, Max was a rotten, spoiled, horrible child and he ruined the movie.
Swanner: It may have worked in 1963 but today’s audiences want faster pace stories with maybe some dialog. I do think it’s a great job at adapting this very small story but small is what this movie should have been. The creatures are done really well but I needed something more than just playing and fighting. It was like a very long commercial for Ritalin. The kid’s an awful brat and the creatures are like visiting a senior home where they get all liquored up at night and have only regrets in the morning. After the movie…I knew the feeling
Judd: Today’s audiences also want mindless pop-culture references, editing that could induce a seizure, and fart jokes. While I do love a good fart joke, WTWTA is above all that. It’s undoubtedly an art film. My question is: is it an art film for kids, for adults, for adults with kids, for mature kids, or for immature adults? It is definitely NOT a movie for adults who don’t want kids. It’s birth control on film. If you were undecided before, you’ll be scheduling a vasectomy after.
Swanner: Even though this book came out when I was a kid it was never a favorite but then I was an angelic child. Destroying things and fighting were never part of my play time. I dreamt of spiders that can write and chocolate factories not horrible creatures. Wow, I was really waxing rhapsodic; I think that’s who the audience really is… the folks that still hold the book dear whether they are 5, 50 or 80.
Judd: If it weren’t for the horrible child Max, I would have liked the movie. I liked all the monsters. Carol, voiced by James Gandolfini, was a reflection of Max, but because he was really a monster it was more palatable. Paul Dano played a wimpy goat that didn’t like to roughhouse – that was the Tom character. Then there was Judith, voiced by Catherine O’Hara, who berates Max and wants to eat him as soon as he shows up on their island. She was my favorite.
Swanner: Judith is you… That’s why she was your favorite. Just because I don’t like to be hit with a dirt clod doesn’t make me the goat and he wasn’t wimpy. I’m glad you liked it, I didn’t. I thought it looked good but I needed more, sorry.
Swanner: 2 Stars
Judd: 4 Stars